Using lived experience, science, and Lifton's Criteria to Diagnose Gender Ideology as a Destructive, Homophobic, Misogynistic, Child Endangering Cult
July 5, 2023
How Gender Ideology Meets the Lifton Criteria for being a cult:
Analysis
(Writer’s Note: A bit on my personal and professional qualifications for writing this article. I will attach at the bottom of the article, my Baccalaureate award winning undergraduate thesis on the post-9/11 era of American politics and media rhetoric using the Robert J. Lifton Criteria for Totalism at the end of the document. I came to read this seminal psychologist’s path-breaking research on “thought reform and behavior modification”- what would colloquially be called brainwashing and coercive control groups as a result of my experiences being sent away to the Synanon cult’s legacy in America, known as the troubled teen industry, which many cult experts have analyzed as such a group of institutions. I have a Bachelor’s in Political Science and Psychology and have dedicated myself to studying coercive control regimes- be they political or non-governmental groups, as a result of my experiences as an adolescent. This predates any gender ideology related views, by more than 15 years, although I have come to see the gender identity industry and so-called trans activist behaviors as a massively dangerous ideology, based on disinformation and fraud. I have come to hold these views as a formerly enthusiastic trans ally- I welcome anyone to watch David Reimer’s post-detransition, pre-suicide interviews on YouTube, as well as Chloe Cole, and countless other detransitioners who have bravely told their stories, hoping for a wake-up call reaching the public. I would also encourage readers to follow womenarehuman.com and Reduxx Magazine, which reports on the travesty of various aspects of gender ideology and how it harms women and children all over the country and world. I will respond to feedback, but not without sufficient assurance that people have truly examined the evidence.)
Robert Jay Lifton is a PhD in Psychology whose book, Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism was first published in 1961, and was in part based on those American servicemen coming back from the Korean War. It was part of a larger interest in the US in understanding “mind control” and “brainwashing”, including as a result of the New Age Human Potential Movement and the social changes that came with the “hippie” counterculture and these phenomena being associated with cultic groups of many kinds, political, psychotherapeutic, and religious included. There soon followed the MK-Ultra experiments by federal government institutions. While the public interest in “mind control” waned temporarily, Dr. Lifton wrote a new book in 2017 in relation to political polarization, influence operations on social media, and radicalization of political groups across the political spectrum.
The Eight Criteria for Thought Reform: Milieu Control, mystical manipulation, demand for purity, confession, sacred science, loading the language, doctrine over person, and the dispensing of existence.
1. Milieu Control: Lifton defines milieu control as control of human communication, which is interesting when applied to the online world and the extent of captured media institutions, the promotion of gender ideology on many social media platforms- indeed countless detransitioners report subjecting themselves to pro-transition content on Tumblr, YouTube, Instagram, Twitter, and Reddit. His words, “Milieu control never succeeds in becoming absolute and its own human apparatus can- when permeated by outside information- become subject to discordant noise beyond that of any mechanical apparatus. To totalist administrators, however, these occurrences are no more than incorrect uses of the apparatus. To thought reform participants, there may be doubt about who is telling what to whom, but the fact that extensive information about everyone is being conveyed to the authorities is always known. At the center of this self-justification is their assumption of omniscience, their conviction that reality is their exclusive possession. Having experienced what they consider to be the ultimate truth and having the need to dispel any possible inner doubts of their own, they consider it their duty to create an environment of containing no more and no less than this ‘truth’…One exposed to milieu control experiences a disruption of the self and outside world. Deprived of the combination of external information and inner reflection which anyone requires to test the realities of his environment and to maintain a measure of identity separate from it. Instead, he or she is called upon to make an absolute polarization of the real, (the prevailing ideology) and the unreal (everything else),” (Origins of Totalism, Lifton, pg. 358-359, 398-399 of 510)
Examples of milieu control, besides the manufactured “evidence” of gender identity theory of Dr. John Money and his experiment on David Reimer, (
, https://www.spiked-online.com/2023/02/05/dr-john-money-and-the-sinister-origins-of-gender-ideology/ ) among trans activists and gender ideologues is seen in the “cancel culture” that allows for left-wing silencing of a huge variety of those attempting to speak out and get information to the public, to counter several falsehoods at the center of gender ideology and the outright lies upon which support for medicalization has always been based. (https://musingsofpaul325885992.wordpress.com/trans-rhetoric-menu/ ,
) Nonetheless, even scientific opposition to gender ideology, as well as the “lived experiences” of its victims, including detransitioners and female students and athletes who have suffered an erosion of their sex-based rights
There is additionally the use of infiltrating institutions, including former LGB advocacy and women’s rights and women’s empowerment organizations, media institutions, and running for public office in order to control both official policy and the narrative, which has allowed for the mainstream indoctrination of the public, with many people still repeating thought-terminating cliches, such as “Gender is a social construct,” , “Trans women are women”, “Sex is a spectrum,” “gender medicine is suicide prevention,” While there is publicly available information debunking the gender treatments, including use of the chemical castration drug, Lupron, known colloquially as puberty blockers, wrong sex-hormones and controlled substances estrogen and testosterone, as well as the surgeries, top and bottom, with staggering failure and complication rates.
Worst of all is the lie about it being a suicide prevention treatment, which has persisted in the United States in particular, as in places like the United Kingdom, Finland, the Netherlands and Sweden, all countries that embraced the use of gender “medicine” even for minor aged children, and subsequently reversed these policies and shut down the clinics, due to an inability to replicate a single claim made by Dr. John Money or several other researchers and organizational claims advocating that gender transition was scientifically based, and included several mental health benefits including a reduction in suicide rates amongst gender dysphoric individuals. This is covered in detail by the book, Time To Think: Inside the Collapse of the Tavistock Gender Clinic for Children by Hannah Barnes, as well as the Helen Joyce and Kathleen Stock books cited below, and in the whistleblower opinion editorial in The Free Press by Jamie Reade, a former employee of such a gender clinic for minors in St. Louis, (https://www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-i-was-saving-trans-kids ) and Tablet Magazine piece by a Finnish doctor who used to support “gender medicine” and now she speaks out against it, including in describing the claims of suicide prevention by transing minors as “willful and irresponsible disinformation,” (https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/science/articles/finland-youth-gender-medicine)
(including Helen Joyce, author of the book Trans: Where Ideology Meets Reality, Abagail Shirer, author of the book, Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters , Dr. Kathleen Stock, former British academic and author of Material Girls: Why Reality Matters for Feminism and the intimidation and efforts at silencing through violence and censorship/deplatforming of countless women and girl’s rights advocates like J.K. Rowling and Kellie Jay Keene in the United Kingdom and Amy Sousa, researcher at Brown University Lisa Littman, and female athlete Riley Gaines in the United States. Bennett, C. 2020, “Making a Demon out of JK Rowling is a Wretched Sport, Born of Misogyny and Resentment,” The Guardian, & Kearns, M. (2023) “The Assault of Riley Gaines Proves a Point,” The National Review. April 12, 2023, & Krispenz, A. & Bertrams, A. (2023) “Understanding Left-Wing Authoritarianism: Relations to the Dark Personality Traits, Altruism, and Social Justice Commitment,” Current Psychology. University of Bern, Switzerland.
Krispenz, A. & Bertrams, A. (2022) “Involvement in LGBTQ+ Activism is Related to Pathological Narcissistic Grandiosity & Virtue Signaling,” Institute of Educational Science. Pgs. 1-17. University of Bern, Switzerland,)
2. Mystical Manipulation: “This manipulation assumes a no holds barred character, and uses every device at the milieu’s command, no matter how bizarre or painful. Initiated from above, it seeks to provoke specific patterns of behavior and emotion in such a way that these will appear to have arisen spontaneously from within the environment. This element of planned spontaneity, directed as it is by an omniscient group, must assume, for the manipulated, a near-mystical quality…” (Lifton, pg. 400/510)
Mystical manipulation is seen with some of the most infamous cults in history, including Jim Jones’ People’s Temple staged “healings” of the disabled and the ill, the Moonies’ mass weddings, the Oregon-based Rajneeshees’ effort to rig a local election by poisoning the salad bar at a local diner just before Election Day, to decrease voter turnout among non-cult member residents of the town. Other examples include inducing traumatic states in LGAT (Large group awareness trainings) focused cults like EST/The Forum, the troubled teen industry, and NXVIM. In these settings, the leaders of the coercive control group will subject participants to extremely distressing experiences, such as “Attack Therapy” or “running anger” (the latter of which is much like Primal Scream therapy) combined with sleep deprivation, using music to heighten the experience, going long without bathroom, food, or water breaks, and is followed by intense love-bombing, thus cementing the trauma-bonding and artificially inducing euphoric feelings in participants.
So too do we see mystical manipulation with the gender cult, in fact, we see many different types of mystical manipulation in relation to the gender industry and cult. The most obvious example of this, is what we have seen in schools, in the United States and elsewhere in the world gender ideology and “medicine” has spread. Kids claiming “trans” or “non-binary” identities has increased an many times in recent years, and it is not because there is more acceptance of these phenomena, , or availability of wrong-sex hormones, Lupron (also called puberty blockers, but they are what we use to chemically castrate sex offenders) and corrupt surgeons willing to mutilate children. Lisa Littman is a researcher at Brown University who has been researching instances of “rapid-onset gender dysphoria” and its more than thousand percent increase in teenage girls, not the traditional group treated for this condition until very recently. Her research is attached to the sources below for this criterion, as is Abagail Shirer’s book on the social contagion propensity in adolescent girls, as seen with eating disorders and self-harm with earlier generations and to an extent, these social contagions have remained present in addition to gender dysphoric clusters of teen girls, often in the same schools and friend groups.
Filling young children’s heads with biology denial and overly sexualized content, filling the school libraries with often straight propaganda, that tells kids that whether they are a boy or a girl has nothing to do with their biological sex, that there are “treatments available” for them to “be happy”, inviting males with autogynephilia to perform in Womanface, essentially hyper-sexualized performances akin to a Minstrel Show, but for misogyny enthusiasts rather than racist ideologies. Helping minors “transition” to a different name, with a different wardrobe, and different pronouns, giving them resources on how they can obtain dangerous breast binders, and doctors who will put them on a path to medical transition- many, many times all of this going on explicitly withheld from students’ parents by the schools. And as a result of all of this grooming- there is no other word for it but grooming, which is precisely what the advocacy group Gays Against Groomers calls all of this- an organization for which I am deeply grateful as a bisexual woman and survivor of childhood sexual abuse and severe developmental trauma, that they are a voice of those of us in the Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual community who are absolutely horrified by what is going on with gender ideology, and see it as a horrific foreign invader of our movement, an example I will touch on in just a moment. Planned Parenthood clinics now all over the country are doling out testosterone pills and injections to underage girls, estrogen to underage boys, all with just the requirement that the child, who can show up accompanied to the clinic, have no proof of the sign-off of a parent or guardian, signs an “informed consent” form, which, as countless detransitioned females have specified does not include the adverse conditions to their fertility. Additionally, there is endless media content out there attempting to normalize this hideous barbarity like the reality tv show on Jazz Jennings and the male child beginning the path of medical castration and sterilization at only two years old. There’s been “Transparent” and Bruce Jenner’s discussions of his “transition” and autogynephilia on E! News reality show Keeping Up with the Kardashians. There are also tremendous amounts of content on social media, including by adults like Jeffrey Marsch, and the kids themselves. There are often adults in these communities posing as children and filling their heads with notions, according to detransitioners and other investigations, that if “you don’t feel comfortable in your body during puberty, that means you’re trans” and other universal experiences that any preteen and teen can relate to and apply to themselves. Gender Mapper is also linked below where one can see the entire map of gender clinics for minors that have exploded across the United States, is also linked below. And there you have it. The explosion in gender dysphoric kids is easily explained by the promotion of “drag” entertainment for kids, “trans” and “gender” propaganda being classroom material, even school libraries filled with more of this propaganda, and even the full-scale invasion and occupation of formerly sex-segregated spaces and sports under Title IX and the 14th amendment rights of female students by biological males. Female students and athletes are bullied into silence or punished severely for speaking up for these outrageous violations of their rights. Combined with milieu control and echo chamber, self-curated partisan media specifically, and the capture of countless media organizations by gender ideology, and most importantly, the use of the “suicide prevention” lie backed up by emotional blackmail, and you can artificially conceal the objective truth: this is not organic. This a well-funded pharmaceutical and Big Tech boosted movement, complete with counterparts to the right-wing billionaires like the Murdoch family and the Mercers in the United Kingdom behind it. I have attached a few videos of investigator Jennifer Bilek on following the money behind gender ideology. All these things conceal the very real majority of Americans opposed to gender ideology and artificially increase the number of children and vulnerable young adults who are seeking drugs and surgeries.
Another example of mystical manipulation in the gender cult is the rebranding of a long documented sexual paraphilia afflicting men and boys called autogynephilia as “trans” due to gender dysphoria. I am not the first person to wonder if the far-left political operatives and media figures knew that their precious “trans women” were in fact, cross-dressing fetishists with a sexual paraphilia, sexual arousal at the “degrading” experiences of being “female” and arousal in violating the boundaries of women and girls, often as the result of “cissy hypno porn” – I have attached links below to Genevieve Gluck doing interviews and informational videos, and the website of pro-woman, pro-child safeguarding coverage of how gender ideology is harming women on this phenomenon, including on Robert Hogges, also known as Monica Helms, a former US Army man who is responsible for designing the “trans” flag, and his organizing homophobic, misogynistic groups like “A Sorority Without Women” comprised of other autogynephilic males, where they made a point of studying feminist movements and the LGB community to devise strategies to take over these groups and corrupt their original purpose, a phenomenon we’ve seen with Stonewall, Women’s March, National Organization for Women, United Nations Women, Autostraddle, and others. I will also attach links to Hogges’ own writings, where he concedes all these ugly truths about his movement, for everyone to read and fact-check independently if you choose. The systematic capture of media organizations, government bodies, public school curriculum, legal and policy documents to erase females/women/girls, the use of cancel culture and public shaming for stating unpopular views, the rebranding of autogynephilia as “gender dysphoria” and “transgender” and the explosion of accessible gender drugs and surgeries, with or without the parents’ consent, and it appears as though this meteoric rise in “trans” and “nonbinary” kids is altogether inexplicable, because more than half the story has been concealed from people, about what the truth is about what is driving the explosion of youths confused and dysphoric and self-sterilizing and mutilating kids and young adults. (https://www.city-journal.org/article/the-real-story-behind-drag-queen-story-hour , https://defendinged.org/resources/gender-ideology-101/ , https://skepticalinquirer.org/video/the-ideological-subversion-of-biology-jerry-coyne-and-luana-maroja/#:~:text=They%E2%80%99ll%20discuss%20how%20the%20field%20of%20evolutionary%20and,most%20importantly%2C%20what%20can%20be%20done%20about%20it https://www.newsweek.com/coming-bipartisan-backlash-public-school-wokeness-opinion-1584346
https://wjla.com/features/i-team/loudoun-county-public-school-parents-called-domestic-terrorists-scott-smith-sex-assault-victim-father-wants-apology
https://spectator.org/radical-gender-ideology-schools/
Loudon County VA
https://littmanresearch.com/publications/
https://www.amazon.com/Irreversible-Damage-Transgender-Seducing-Daughters/dp/1684510317 )
Erin Friday, mother. activist for parental rights
https://www.gaysagainstgroomers.com/about
Chloe Cole detransitioner interview
https://www.gendermapper.org/
https://www.youtube.com/live/xeg0B2EaDZw?feature=share Riley Gaines, Crain & Company
Riley Gaines and Kim Jones on ACLU capture by gender ideology, biology denial, contempt for women’s and girl’s rights.
Genevieve Gluck 1 WPATH
Genevieve Gluck 2 autogynephilia rebrand as gender dysphoria.
https://www.youtube.com/live/mS8ZfFZ-Bc0?feature=share Genevieve Gluck 3 autogynephilia, WPATH with Graham Linehan.
Genevieve Gluck 4 truth about trans
Genevieve Gluck 5 Origins of the Trans Flag
Genevieve Gluck 6 cissy hypno porn
Genevieve Gluck 7 trans cult
https://reduxx.info/trans-pride-flag-creator-71-announces-adoption-of-14-year-old-trans-daughter/ Hogges
https://www.amazon.com/Tales-Two-Gendered-Mind-Monica-Helms/dp/1481271237 Hogges book
https://www.amazon.com/More-Than-Just-Monica-Helms-ebook/dp/B07PV74QDZ/ref=sr_1_2?qid=1689116038&refinements=p_27%3AMonica+F.+Helms&s=books&sr=1-2&text=Monica+F.+Helms Hogges aka Helms More Than Just a Flag
https://reduxx.info/change-org-deletes-12-year-old-girls-petition-calling-for-single-sex-school-bathrooms/ Petition by 12-year-old girl for single sex bathrooms deleted by Change.org
https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/252268/clerical-error-wipes-out-thousands-of-public-comments-on-title-ix-gender-identity-rule-as-deadline-arrives Biden administration deletes Title IX comments from angry women, girls on Title IX corruption/warping into a boy’s and men’s sexual rights statute.)
3. Demand for Purity
“In the thought reform milieu, as in all situations of ideological totalism, the experiential world is sharply divided into the pure and impure, into the impure, into the absolutely good and the absolutely evil. The good and the pure are of course those ideas and feelings and actions consistent with the totalist ideology and policy; anything else is apt to be relegated to the bad and the impure. Nothing human is immune from the flood of stern moral judgements. All taints and poisons which contribute to the existing state of impurity must be searched out and eliminated…one must look upon his impurities as originating from outside influences- that is, from the ever-threatening world beyond the closed, totalist ken. Therefore, one of his best ways to relieve his burden of guilt is to denounce, continuously and hostilely, these same outside influences. The more guilty he feels, the greater his hatred, and the more threatening they seem. In this manner, the universal tendency towards projection is nourished and institutionalized, leading to mass hatred, purges of heretics, and to political and religious holy wars.,” (409, Lifton.)
Now this one will be fairly obvious, to anyone who has ever heard the term “purity testing” in relation to woke politics. Even professional media figures have lost count of how many individuals, but especially women have been forced out of their jobs, or to be blackballed professionally for opposing gender ideology and defending reality. While six years ago, cancel culture was a weapon of Me-Too movement activists, “cancelling” males who had a pattern of predatory and abusive conduct towards women and kids, a way to prevent them from ruling the roost even if these men and their crimes had passed statute of limitations or would be otherwise ineligible for civil or criminal litigation. Now, gender nonconforming lesbians like Dr. Kathleen Stock are “deplatformed” for speaking the truth about the impossibility for our species of changing our biological sex, and the ways in which law and policies that give males the privilege of acting to intimidate and violate the sexual boundaries of women and children. Thought-terminating slogans such as “trans-women are women” which can be proved false in a heartbeat, are chanted by brainwashed violent and sexually abusive males as well as their tragic brainwashed allies among women on the left. The entire history of civilization reflects that women and girls are reasonable to see males as possible predators and dangers to their physical and emotional health. But in the post-truth, evolution denying, and misogynistic cult of gender ideology, women and girls are denied any right of consent or privacy or physical safety, crime statistics being almost entirely males as the perpetrators and females as the victims of sexual offenses are dismissed and only pure adherence to the ideology of the cult will be acceptable. In the gender cult, women who assert their opposition to being deprived of sexual boundaries and participating in the telling of compelled falsehoods are heretics, as are the LGB who are opposed to gender ideology, and most of all, detransitioners are treated as blaspheming heretics and traitors to the TQ+.
(sources for demand for purity: https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/proving-the-point/
)
4. The cult of confession
“Closely related to the demand for purity is an obsession with personal confession. Confession is carried out beyond its ordinary religious, legal, and therapeutic expressions to the point of becoming a cult in itself. There is the demand that one confesses to crimes one has not actually committed, to sinfulness that is artificially induced, in the name of a cure that is arbitrarily imposed. Such demands are made possible not only by the ubiquitous human tendencies towards guilt and shame but also by the need to give expression to these tendencies. In totalist hands, confession becomes a means of exploitation, rather than offering solace for, these vulnerabilities. Totalist confession takes on a number of special meanings. It is first a vehicle for the kind of pressure purification which we have just discussed, a means of maintaining a perpetual inner emptying or a psychological purge of impurity, Second, it is an act of symbolic self-surrender, the expression of the merging of the individual and environment. Third, it is a means of maintaining an ethos of total exposure- of a policy of making public everything possible about the life experiences, thoughts, and passions of each individual, and especially those elements which might be regarded as derogatory…” (Lifton, 403/510)
Elements of the cult of confession can be seen in cancel culture generally, and specifically to the matter of gender ideology. Women in particular are viciously hounded; their employers publicly exhorted to terminate and blackball them from their professions for simply speaking the truth. In the summer of 2022, both lifelong liberal women in show business, Macy Gray and Bette Middler were tormented for making factually accurate statements about the inability of humans to change sex, and that in Gray’s case, just days after her appearance on Piers Morgan’s news program to state that truthfully, males who get penile inversion surgery (and they are in the extreme of trans-identified males, over 90% keep their male genitalia) do not become women, she was hounded and threatened with professional and economic and social blackballing unless she apologized, which she did, therefore betraying biological reality and related oppression of women and girls around the world. Similarly, Bette Middler was berated and defamed following a tweet criticizing the dehumanizing language used for females- uterus-havers, pregnant people, chestfeeders, that misogynistic authoritarians on the left have come up with to gender neutralize language against the will and consent of women and girls. She eventually and actually quickly apologized for advocating for the supermajority of Americans, and the fifty-one percent of the population that are female- overwhelmingly deserving of their individual rights and supported by an enormous bipartisan majority of the electorate. Nonetheless, people are exhorted for apologies for acknowledging reality, especially women. In the case of the TQ+ cabal, biological males like Dylan Mulvaney, “Fallon” Fox, Will “Lia” Thomas, Robert Hogge aka Monica Helms, and countless “queer” theorists, can keep their penises and confess to autogynephilic and pedophilic yearnings, and nonetheless continue to shape policies on gender “medicine” and self-id policies. Confessions, as you will see in the sources, of such males having sexual impulses to fetishize rape as something they wish would happen to them as they see it as the ultimate female experience, fetishes of child sexual abuse urges, fetishizing violence against women and children, none of these things once confessed to are disqualifying to be “included” in policy discussions, female only spaces and granted access to women and kids.
(Sources for cult of confession:
Queer Theorists endorse or at a minimum refuse to condemn pedophilia, child rape.
https://www.bing.com/videos/search?q=macy+gray+what+is+a+woman&&view=detail&mid=45C1F06372CA073CB62645C1F06372CA073CB626&&FORM=VRDGAR&ru=%2Fvideos%2Fsearch%3Fq%3Dmacy%2Bgray%2Bwhat%2Bis%2Ba%2Bwoman%26FORM%3DHDRSC6 Macy Gray apologizes for stating the fact that taking wrong sex hormones and penile inversion surgery does not in fact turn a man into a woman.
https://ew.com/celebrity/bette-midler-clarifies-tweet-had-no-intention-of-transphobia/ Bette Midler, lifelong liberal Democrat and Jewish American woman has to apologize for objecting to women being referred to with dehumanizing, degrading, misogynistic language like uterus havers
https://www.peaktrans.org/autogynephilia/
https://reduxx.info/top-academic-behind-fetish-site-hosting-child-sexual-abuse-fantasy-push-to-revise-wpath-guidelines/ World Professional Association of Transgender Health hosts for more than 1.5 decades to child sexual abuse material “Eunuch Archive”
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/german-kindergarten-ban-children-doctor-game-kdln8bpxj
Mather, R. & Jefferson, K. (2016) “The Authoritarian Voter? The Psychology and Values of Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders Support,” Journal of Scientific Psychology. University of Central Oklahoma, Department of Psychology & the Winston Churchill Center for Global Engagement, Westminster College. Pgs. 1-8.
Moore-Carrillo, J. “Georgetown University’s Free Speech Project: Radical Feminist Program in Seattle Draws Protests, Attempted Disruptions,”
Norris, P. (2020) “Closed Minds? Is Cancel Culture Stifling Academic Freedom and Debate in Political Science?” Harvard Kennedy School of Government. Pgs. 1-29.
Ok, E.; Qian, Y. et al. (2021) “Signaling Virtuous Victimhood as Indicators of Dark Triad Personalities,” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Personality Processes, Individual Differences. Vol. 120, No. 6, Pgs. 1634-1661.
https://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/biden_administration/most_americans_oppose_transgender_agenda Rasmussen post-Riley Gaines and Will “Lia” Thomas scandal on opoosing gender ideology.
autogynephilia including disturbing selections from the entire subgrenre of internet porn that autogynephilic and predatory males now dress up in womanface, and will film themselves masturbating in women’s toilets, including exposing their penises to the underage and of age but non-consenting females who use these spaces. The males and females on the authoritarian misogynistic and rape-sympathizing left seeks to deny these crimes by males and even the existence of autogynephilia. It is important therefore to remember that such males are telegraphing their deep hatred of women and girls- if anyone should be cancelled, it is the left-wing woke misogynistic males who have sold out every woman and child in their lives, to the sexual fetishes of predatory males.)
5. The Sacred Science:
“The totalist milieu maintains an aura of sacredness around its basic dogma, holding it out as an ultimate moral vision for the ordering of human existence. This sacredness is evident in the prohibition (whether or not explicit) against the questioning of basic assumptions, and in the reverence which is demanded for the originators of the Word. While thus transcending ordinary assumptions of logic, however, the milieu at the same time makes an exaggerated claim of airtight logic, of absolute “scientific” precision. Thus, the ultimate moral vision becomes an ultimate science, and one who dares to criticize it or harbor even unspoken alternative ideas, becomes not only immoral and irrelevant, but also “unscientific…”
Like the demand for purity, this criterion is fairly obvious. We can see it with something that just happened this week in the United States Congress, where all Democratic lawmakers walked out when a doctor tried to explain via testimony the risks of Lupron (also known as puberty blockers but are in fact a chemical castration drug being used off-label on children in huge doses not approved by the Food & Drug Administration. But the “sacred science” goes back all the way to Dr. John Money, at Johns Hopkins University, who is considered the founding father of “gender identity” theory, and who.
certainly, did his best to sabotage the public’s access to accurate scientifically valid information by falsifying his study results on David Reimer, considered the Patient Zero for an experiment to test Dr. Money’s theory that gender identification was not principally about biological sex/nature but how the child is raised/nature. Reimer was an identical twin male from Canada whose infant-age circumcision went terribly wrong, accidentally burning off the infant’s penis. His brother, the second of the two in line for circumcision was taken home without completing the procedure. The Reimer parents were agonized but had no idea what could be done for their son who now was missing a penis. His parents, young and uneducated, saw Dr. John Money on television discussing his theory about gender being principally a matter of nature, rather than innate biological sex, and brought their son to see the doctor at Johns Hopkins University, where he was treated with hormone therapy and surgery, the doctor forbade the parents from telling the boys that David, at that point renamed Brenda, or anyone else he had been born a boy. He directed the parents to dress him in girl’s clothing and give him girl’s toys- and never to tell a soul, including their children, that David (then known as Brenda) had been born a boy. However, his patient zero eventually wrestled the truth out of his parents at about fourteen years old, (one can assume that a castrated and surgical wound created in its place surgery by the age of fourteen, would have created medical confusion for the poor child, as he would have gone to the OBGYN for not getting his period, and that OBGYN and any OBGYN investigating a post-operative biological male who was allegedly a girl, would discover he didn’t have his period because he lacked a cervix, uterus, fallopian tubes, ovaries, in essence any female reproductive organs. The boy eventually detransitioned and spoke publicly including to Oprah, I have links included below on Money and Reimer. However, Reimer was unable to catch up with the lies that his “doctor” John Money blithely told the world and medical community in the Western world at large. They say that a lie can travel around the world before the truth has time to put on its shoes and lace them up, and this tragic case of that being true caused Reimer to eventually commit suicide, and his identical twin brother, who was not transed but nonetheless died just a few years later after his brother of a drug overdose, demonstrates the evil of the people involved in this ideology, their willingless to manipulate and outright falsify medical journal data, not dissimilarly to pharmaceutical companies in the opioid epidemic, as well as the New England Journal of Medicine Seroquel scandal, as well as the troubled teen industry. It is a systemic issue of the United States private for-profit healthcare system. But notably, recently, countries that have not-for-profit healthcare systems such as Sweden, Finland, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, and Germany have all reversed course on transing minors due to a lack of empirical evidence.
(Sources for “sacred science”
- https://www.spiked-online.com/2023/02/05/dr-john-money-and-the-sinister-origins-of-gender-ideology/amp/ John Money and David Reimer
-
Detrans David Reimer, pre suicide interview with Oprah
-
David Reimer last public interview before suicide
-
David Reimer John Money
- https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/science/articles/finland-youth-gender-medicine Finland bans “transing” kids.
- https://genderreport.ca/the-swedish-u-turn-on-gender-transitioning/ Swedish ban
- https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/tavistock-centre-gender-clinic-young-people-children-nhs-report-b987475.html British investigation and closure of Tavistock Gender Service for Minors
-
John Money/Reimer twins
- https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0202330 Lisa Littman Research
- https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/07/10/jailed-male-sex-offenders-fake-trans-women-prisoners/ Males faking “trans” identities to gain access to women’s prisons.
-
detransitioner regret
-
- https://feministlegal.org/castrating-children-in-the-service-of-male-sexuality/ Russian Skoptsy sect similarities to child castration enthusiasts of 21st century gender cult
-
https://twitter.com/WomenReadWomen/status/1467082310881529859?s=20
Russian Skoptsy sect similarities to 21st century gender cult
- https://reduxx.info/top-trans-medical-association-collaborated-with-castration-child-abuse-fetishists/ WPATH 2 on top “trans” health association collaborated with child abuse fetishists.
6. Loading the Language
“The language of the totalist environment is characterized by the thought-terminating cliché. The most far-reaching and complex of human problems are compressed into brief, highly reductive, definitive-sounding phrases, easily memorized and easily expressed. These become the start and finish of any ideological analysis…Totalist language, then, is repetitiously centered on an all-encompassing jargon, prematurely abstract, relentlessly judging, and to anyone but its most devoted advocate, tirelessly dull. In Lionel Trilling’s phrase, the language of nonthought,” (Lifton, 407/510)
Whether readers have realized it before now or not, they are very likely familiar with the “loading the language” tactics of the authoritarian death cult of gender ideology. “Trans women are women” “To ban sterilizing kids and to allow sexual boundaries for women and girls is ‘genocide’, (never mind that the definition of genocide is a deliberate killing or extermination of an ethnic or religious or racial group, and therefore, there couldn’t be a ‘trans’ genocide even if people wanted, never mind that trans people are exponentially more likely to be the perpetrators of crimes than its victims, never mind that the femicide rates in countries that have been captured by gender ideology is tens of thousands of times higher than that of any trans-identified people, and NEVER MIND that every genocidal regime in history and the present including the Nazis, the Russians’ genocide of Ukrainians, Rwanda, and that of the Chinese state’s genocide of the Uighurs all involved interfering with reproduction including through STERILIZATION of people to prevent reproduction- to its adherents, none of these facts matter, and they won’t let historical realities get in the way of their predatory instincts towards women and children.) Another example of loading the language is “sports are a human right” to rationalize destroying the opportunities, safety, fairness, and dignity of female athletes by allowing males to self-identify into female athletic competitions. Never mind the fact that there are only recommendations, based on science and the CONSENT or lack thereof of female athletes, to require biological males to compete in the category of their birth sex, or in an open category. The gender-captured authoritarian and misogynistic left doesn’t care about women or girls or their lack of consent or the myriad examples of female athletes being injured, like Payton McNabb, a high school volleyball playing female from North Carolina who was left with PERMANENT INJURIES following being required to compete against a trans-identified male on the opposing volleyball for girls’ team and being hit in the face with the ball. The unhinged totalist gender zealots’ resorts to thought-terminating slogans, sometimes while engaging in violence against women’s rights activists like Riley Gaines and Kelly Jay Keene. I have cited all of these examples below.
(Sources for Loading the Language: https://musingsofpaul325885992.wordpress.com/2020/09/13/trans-rhetoric-part-1/ thought-terminating illogical, reality denying gender thought terminating cliches
https://fairplayforwomen.com/criminality/ (transwo)men retain male criminality patterns
https://www.womenarehuman.com/the-difference-between-male-criminality-female-criminality-nz-over-incarceration-of-women/ Male vs female criminality
https://www.womenarehuman.com/male-transgender-person-arrested-for-molesting-several-children/ trans child molester
https://reduxx.info/first-trans-representative-in-new-hampshire-arrested-after-stalking-woman-violating-restraining-order/ “trans” representative from New Hampshire arrested for stalking, violating restraining order
https://reduxx.info/first-openly-transgender-state-representative-arrested-on-child-pornography-charges/ same New Hampshire politician arrested on child porn charges
https://www.womenarehuman.com/male-transgender-inmate-sent-to-youth-prison-after-impregnating-female-inmates/ trans identified males raping women in prison
https://www.womenarehuman.com/yet-another-drag-queen-arrested-for-child-sexual-abuse-images/ drag queen male arrested for child porn
https://www.womenarehuman.com/transgender-neo-nazi-leader-bank-robber-fast-tracked-for-gender-surgery/ neo-nazi/far-right incel to violent trans identified male pipeline
https://www.rebelnews.com/transgender_swimmer_lia_thomas_exposed_report investigation of Will “Lia” Thomas social media accounts reveal autogynephilic tendencies, liked images of men beating women.
https://www.mmanews.com/news/fallon-fox-punching-terfs Male MMA fighter who fractured female opponents’ skulls brags about “beating up TERFs”
https://reduxx.info/exclusive-man-who-beat-two-babies-to-death-allegedly-awaiting-breast-implants-at-california-womens-prison/ California inmate awaiting breast implants transferred to female prison after conviction for beating his own infant daughters to death.
https://fairplayforwomen.com/campaigns/sports-campaign/ differences and advantages in males over female athletes
https://www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/the-new-misogyny/
https://thepostmillennial.com/nurse-investigated-for-saying-biological-sex-is-real
Affirmation Generation Documentary
Hormone Health Crisis, lack of empirical evidence for “transing” minors with Will Malone, endocrinologist
detransitioner lesbian interview
St Louis whistleblower from gender clinic for minors op-ed
https://boysvswomen.com/#/
showing biological differences between males and females in sports, inherent misogyny of allowing males into female sports
https://www.foxnews.com/us/pro-trans-activists-swarm-elderly-woman-banned-ymca-demanding-trans-employee-leave-locker-room violence by TRAs towards 80-year-old woman banned from pool for objection to grown man in women’s locker-room supervising 3 year old girls in lockerroom
Amy Sousa on John Money/ Reimer twins
Amy Sousa, gaslighting women about sexual assault and predatory mimics in animal and plant kingdom
Payton McNabb calls for no more biological males in female sports after being left with permanent life-limiting injuries after hit in the face with ball spiked by trans-identified biological male.
Payton McNabb Megyn Kelly interview
Megyn Kelly on the lies that harm women and girls of gender ideology
Loading the language with mother of a female swimmer Kim Jones
Tennessee Democratic lawmaker spouts disinformation and totalist talking points on gender “medicine”
Gaines describes being physically assaulted, taken hostage by unhinged men in dresses screaming “trans women are women, trans rights are human rights,”
Kelly Jay Keene nearly murdered by male trans activists in New Zealand
Kelly Jay Keene on how trans movement uses authoritarian tactics and is motivated by misogynistic male hatred of women’s rights )
7. Doctrine Over Person
“This sterile language reflects another characteristic feature of ideological totalism: the subordination of human experience to the claims of doctrine. This primacy of doctrine over person is evident in the continual shift between experience itself and the highly abstract interpretation of such experience- between genuine feelings and spurious cataloguing of feelings. It has much to do with the peculiar aura of half-reality which a totalist environment seems, at least to the outsider, to possess. This tendency in the totalist approach to broad historical events was described in relationship to Chinese communism by John K Fairbank and Mary C. Wright: ‘stock characters like capitalist imperialists from abroad, feudal and semi-feudal reaction at home, the resistance and liberation movements of the people enact a morality play. This melodrama sees aggression, injustice, exploitation, and humiliation engulf the people until salvation comes at last. Mass revolutions require an historical myth as part of their black and white morality, and this is the ideological myth of one of the great revolutions of world history.” (Lifton, 408/510)
Doctrine over person can be seen in many areas of gender ideology. First, biological and evolutionary science, as well as all of human history are discounted, and biological sex, the basis of human reproduction, of same sex attracted persons including gays and bisexuals, opposite sex attraction, and the reproduction of most mammals and plants- is deemed a social construct. Similarly, the experiences of women and girls, the evolutionary instincts to identify people including and especially, males’ biological sex automatically being borne from endless generations of women and girls being raped, assaulted, enslaved, sold, trafficked, beaten, murdered and generally preyed upon by males is discounted, all the advice of countless generations to our daughters, sisters, granddaughters, wives, girlfriends to be careful- go to bathrooms in public in groups, don’t walk home alone, don’t run wearing headphones, listen to their instincts about males as the over ninety percent of sexual criminal offenses, whereas women and girls are the victims of more than ninety percent of sexual criminal offenses, our evolutionary hard wired instincts and training of vulnerable young females to be conscious and modify their behavior based on the realities of males as potentially predatory and violent violations of female sexual boundaries and physical autonomy are dismissed totalistically, as “bigotry”. Moreover, the experiences of detransitioners since patient zero David Reimer are dismissed, derided, denounced by trans zealots. The feelings, hard-won rights, facts, and scientific realities of women and girls, children who were “transed” and regretted it, the reality of Patient Zero David Reimer for gender ideology and his detransition and then suicide, and the suicide of his twin brother, the evolutionarily and trauma informed feelings and rights of women are erased as bigotry. The genocidal regimes histories of sterilization of the target population for extermination are ignored, and gender cultists insist that chemical castration and surgical mutilation of children are “suicide prevention” prevail in the face of absolutely zero empirical evidence. In this way, gender ideology zealots punish heretics of their religious authoritarian cult, including detransitioners, women and girls, and the LGB community who opposes gender ideology. The zealots attack science and the lived experience, crime statistics, and evolutionary instincts of the majority of citizens, and seek to compel belief and false speech in the majority at all costs.
(Sources for “Doctrine Over Person”
-
gender zealots expose misogyny, leftist extremism
-
Zuby calls gender ideology misogyny, filled with falsehoods
-
Zuby gender ideology vs reality
-
Piers Morgan, Jordan Peterson on gender zealotry
-
Boyce on autogynephilia
-
Boyce interview on the psychopathy of gender ideology
-
Boyce interview on Maoist China Defector Xi Van Fleet comparisons to Woke America
-
Endocrinologist on lack of empirical evidence for transing kids
- https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-29832690 The ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF IRAN USING GENDER “MEDICINE” AS MEDICAL CONVERSION THERAPY FOR GAY PEOPLE
-
the side effects of “puberty blockers”
- https://fairplayforwomen.com/campaigns/sports-campaign/
- Menon, P. & Decook, J. (2022) “The Dirtbag Left: Bernie Bros and the Persistence of Left-Wing Misogyny,” Palgrave Handbook of Gendered Violence and Technology
-
Genevieve Gluck and Boyce autogynephilia
-
Genevieve Gluck on why men are becoming ‘girls’
-
Helen Joyce and Gluck on ideology vs reality
- https://reduxx.info/top-trans-medical-association-collaborated-with-castration-child-abuse-fetishists/ Child abuse fetishists involved with WPATH
- https://reduxx.info/uk-man-who-identified-himself-as-female-sentenced-after-sexually-assaulting-woman-in-train-station-bathroom/ trans identified male rapes woman in public bathroom
- https://reduxx.info/brazil-trans-identified-male-assaults-teen-girls-for-advocating-for-single-sex-bathrooms/ bathroom assault trans-identified male perpetrator of female victims
- https://reduxx.info/change-org-deletes-12-year-old-girls-petition-calling-for-single-sex-school-bathrooms/ change.org deletes twelve year old girl’s petition for single sex bathrooms as “hateful”
- https://reduxx.info/uk-teen-girl-hospitalized-after-being-attacked-in-unisex-school-bathroom/ Britsh teen hospitalized after attacked in unisex bathrooms
- https://reduxx.info/women-assaulted-in-tacoma-while-protesting-against-gender-ideology/ Violence against women’s rights activists protesting self-id in Tacoma, Washington State
- https://reduxx.info/aclu-represented-transgender-terrorist-diaper-fetishist-to-secure-gender-self-identification-in-nj-womens-prison/ ACLU represents violent male convict for transfer to women’s prison, demands his “baby diaper fetishist identity be indulged by women’s prison administrators )
8. “The Dispensing of Existence”
“The totalist environment draws a sharp line between those whose right to existence can be recognized, and those who possess no such right. In thought reform, as in Chinese communist practice generally, the world is divided into the ‘people’, (defined as the working class, the peasant class, the petite bourgeoisie, and the national bourgeoisie) and the reactionaries or lackeys of imperialism….Being ’outside the people’ the reactionaries are presumably non-people. Under conditions of ideological totalism, in China and elsewhere, nonpeople have often been put to death, their executioners then becoming guilty of crimes of logic.” ( Lifton, 411/450)
Like the prior criterion, the dispensing of existence of the gender cult has several victims. Women and girls who refuse to consent to being the victims of voyeurism and exhibitionism in public spaces where we undress and are thus, especially vulnerable to sexual assault, those women and girls unwilling to participate in the reductive, misogynistic, and regressive notion that females should sacrifice their own safety, comfort, and rights to accommodate men, are described with totalist dehumanizing language- “TERFS”, “transphobic dykes who won’t suck a transwomen’s girldick, lifelong liberal Democratic Party parents like Erin Friday, lifelong liberal or left-leaning women’s rights activists like Megan Murphy, Kara Dansky, JK Rowling, Kelly Jay Keene, Kathleen Stock, Helen Joyce, and countless others are dismissed, defamed and denounced, even subject to violence and rape, death threats. Detransitioners, like so-called “TERFs” are dehumanized, the objects of hatred, for refusing to consent to becoming once again sexual subhuman objects of males. Detransitioners are derided as “fake” trans people, the whistleblowers of Tavistock and the St Louis Children’s Gender Clinic with unimpeachable leftist credentials are accused of transphobia baselessly. Chloe Cole, who was placed on Lupron, testosterone and given a double mastectomy all by the age of fifteen, was threatened, encouraged to kill herself, and subject to extreme animosity and silencing tactics for her activism to try to ban nationwide these evidence-free atrocities against minors. Women’s rights activists are blackballed professionally and threatened personally. The entire history of obstetrics and guidance on pharmaceuticals and substances for breastfeeding women is erased, and autogynephilic males are prescribed a litany of controlled substances to induce drug discharge to “feed” infants, including Klonopin, Estrogen, and Ambien, as well as FDA unapproved domperidone in order to facilitate the sick fetishes of biological males at the expense of infants not being sexually abused or pharmaceutically poisoned.
(Sources for “The Dispensing of Existence” :
-
Kathleen Stock on her book
-
Chloe Cole testimony as detransitioner
-
Detrans Regret
- https://www.youtube.com/live/1SuJrBndQrQ?feature=share The Dangers and Due Process Violations of “Gender Affirming Care”
-
Detransitioners Megyn Kelly
-
California Brawl between parents and TQ+ activists in California
-
Female Erasure testimony by Riley Gaines
- https://www.amazon.com/Female-Erasure-Gender-Politics-Rights/dp/0997146702/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1WWI6H7STG8MJ&keywords=female+erasure&qid=1690506511&sprefix=female+erasure%2Caps%2C96&sr=8-1 Ruth Barrett Female Erasure
- https://www.amazon.com/Irreversible-Damage-Transgender-Seducing-Daughters/dp/B084YC53BR/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1E3E8LHB1378Z&keywords=irreversible+damage+book+by+abigail+shrier&qid=1690506543&sprefix=irrever%2Caps%2C89&sr=8-1 Irreversible Damage by Abigail Shrier
- https://www.amazon.com/Material-Girls-Reality-Matters-Feminism/dp/B096W6WT6S/ref=sr_1_1?crid=CB2283G7LGE1&keywords=kathleen+stock&qid=1690506600&sprefix=kathleen+stock%2Caps%2C107&sr=8-1 Kathleen Stock, book, “Material Girls: Why Reality Matters for Feminism,”
-
Chloe Cole Detransitioner
-
Jenna Hoch on threats from TRAs
-
Witch Hunts on Women’s Rights
- https://reduxx.info/trans-identified-male-named-miss-greater-derry-2023-takes-home-womens-scholarship/ morbidly obese male steals Pageant win, scholarship from biological females
- https://reduxx.info/trans-identifying-man-with-criminal-record-sues-yoga-studio-for-5-million-after-being-escorted-out-of-womens-locker-room/ more dangers to women and girls of self-ID policies
- https://reduxx.info/breaking-ok-school-sued-by-mother-of-female-student-assaulted-by-transgender-male-in-womens-washroom/ Assaults of girls in school bathrooms by trans-identified males
- https://reduxx.info/japan-rape-crisis-center-denied-funding-after-founder-denounced-as-transphobic/ Rape Crisis center in Japan denied funding for being “transphobic”
- https://reduxx.info/trans-identifying-male-academic-who-claimed-porn-motivated-his-transition-awarded-pulitzer-prize/ “trans” identified male Andrew Long Chu awarded Pullitzer Prize for defining women as “submissive fuckholes”
- https://reduxx.info/trans-activist-who-described-young-girls-as-kinky-featured-on-cover-of-brides-today-india/ “trans” activist male describes little girls as “kinky” featured on Indian magazine cover.
-
https://twitter.com/ReduxxMag/status/1526352853522071552?s=20
“Chest feeding (transwo)men autogynephiles use drug cocktail to induce drug discharge to “feed” infants
- https://4w.pub/breastfeeding-transwomen-scientists-ignore/ DRUG DISCHARGE COCKTAIL in trans-identified males dangerous to infants )
Conclusion:
While if I attempted to cite every source in favor of gender ideology being an authoritarian death cult, based in misogyny and homophobia, and male sexual arousal and their demands to access to women and children, I would never finish this piece and you, dear readers, would never finish reading it. I am happy to provide other sources to readers if asked. The evidence is overwhelming and comes from a wealth of disciplines. My lived experiences not merely as a bisexual woman, or the survivor of male sexual violence, but in the troubled teen industry, have informed my writing and research. It is worth noting that my parents, all parents who were manipulated by the troubled teen industry were told their teens would die of self-destructive inclinations and habits if they didn’t send us away. They were told that we had Oppositional Defiant Disorder, which sounds very much like gender dysphoria, just as the blackmailing of parents with threats and assurances that their kids would die if these self declared experts did not do as they said. I will be completing an article comparing and contrasting the troubled teen industry as soon as possible.
